Hollister felt the train slowly start moving. He lay on his bunk in the darkness, the sensation making him feel as if he needed to put his foot on the floor to keep the world still. After four years of staring at a gray ceiling in his tiny cell, the motion was unsettling.
The flask of whiskey was in his hand, but he hadn’t remembered pulling it from his pocket. He fingered it, wondering why he even bothered buying it. He was no drinker. He sat up and put the flask on the small desk. For some reason, given the speed and insanity of the day’s events, he’d felt compelled to bring whiskey with him. Like nothing would make sense unless he was drunk.
After digging wells and stumbling through day after day of mind-numbing boredom, he was suddenly a free man, conditionally at least. All he had to do was go find some thing-man… beast… he still wasn’t sure-that couldn’t be killed and find a way to kill it.
Sure. Should be easy. Locate some men-things that weren’t men, who hadn’t been seen by a living soul for years at a time, and could apparently appear on a whim to wipe out an entire platoon of armed men and disappear without a trace. What have you gotten yourself into, Jonas? he thought. You didn’t take the time to think. Just like always.
Hollister had been posted to the Michigan 7 th Cavalry, right out of West Point in 1864. His father, Thomas, was a well-to-do farmer in Michigan, and a prominent member of the state Republican party. It had been no problem for the elder Hollister to secure his son’s appointment to the academy. Jonas knew his father had hoped the war would be over before he graduated.
The flaw in his father’s plan had turned out to be Jonas himself. When he arrived at the Point, he fell in love with the place. Even the most mundane marching drill and the endless study couldn’t dampen his enthusiasm. Jonas felt like he’d found his calling, and he attacked his classes with a vigor he hadn’t known he’d possessed. After graduating sixth in his class, he’d taken a commission in the cavalry as a second lieutenant.
And as much as he’d loved West Point, he loved the army more. Jonas Hollister was a born fighter. The way some men are meant for politics or business or medicine, Hollister was made for war. He was a natural tactician and had an easy way with commanding soldiers. When staff meetings were held, maps examined and objectives discussed, Hollister could see the entire field in his mind. He instinctively knew the best ground that must be held or taken, where and how the men should be deployed, when to attack, and when to withdraw.
By the fall of ’sixty-four, the Union was driving the Rebs south out of Northern Virginia. They were winning. The South had lost after Gettysburg, with Grant taking Vicksburg and control of the Mississippi-they just didn’t know it yet. After four months in the saddle, riding with Custer, Hollister had been promoted to colonel, given command of a regiment and caught the eye of General Sheridan.
It all had come apart for Hollister near Winchester in March 1965. The men were tired from chasing Lee all over the Shenandoah Valley. No one understood why the rebels just didn’t give up.
Near a small Virginia town called Lancy’s Gap, Hollister had been ordered by Custer to hold a line south of the town, at the bottom of a long ridge, next to an overgrown apple orchard. It was bad ground.
As always, Hollister saw immediately what would happen. His men would deploy along the fencerow while Custer and his brigade dislodged the rebels from the town. But this is where Custer had it backward. The rebels could retreat at their leisure, cutting through the apple orchard. In those close quarters, with their backs to the fencerow, Hollister’s men lost the advantage of being on horseback. Even if Custer succeeded and the Rebs were running, they would still vastly outnumber his troops and cut Hollister’s men to pieces. It was a god-awful plan.
Hollister should be flanking the rebels from the east, he told Custer. If both companies attacked on two sides, even with Hollister’s smaller force, the remaining rebel force could be caught in the village. A southern retreat would allow Hollister’s men to pursue them on horseback and ride them down.
Custer refused. The plan was in place, the order given by General Sheridan himself.
The sun was not quite up yet, but the heat in Custer’s tent was already starting to rise.
He knew George was drunk on Sheridan’s praise. The previous evening at the staff meeting, Sheridan had told the assembled officers how the dashing Custer had been instrumental in laying the trap here at Lancy’s Gap. It was the worst thing he could have said. Custer had an ego the size of his horse and now he was after glory. If he drove the rebels out, he’d make the papers again, probably get promoted. He had fallen in love with the dangerous tactic of dividing his command so he could attack with a smaller force and carry the day with fewer troops. So far he’d been lucky and Sheridan had never called him on it. But his strategy was about to misfire. Most of their engagements the last month had been against smaller forces of Confederates in situations where the rebels were tired, running out of ammo, and desperate. Here, it was different. Jubal Early’s men were battle hardened and maybe running low on supplies and ammunition, but these men still knew how to fight. It wasn’t going to be as easy as Custer thought.
“Sir,” Hollister had said that morning inside Custer’s tent, “with all due respect, General…”
Custer held up a hand.
“I know what you’re going to say, Jonas, and you’re wrong. These Rebs have been on the move for weeks with no food and very little ammunition, but their only choice is to fight. Stand your ground and follow your orders. You’ll get a few runners, stragglers, maybe a company at most. On horseback they’ll be easy pickings.” Custer sat at the campaign desk in his tent. He was immaculately dressed; his boots were sparkling. It was a funny thing for Hollister to notice, but he glanced down at his own boots and saw that they were covered in mud and the big toe on his left foot was poking through.
“General… George… I’m begging you. This is wrong. If you’re even halfway successful, they won’t stand and fight. They’re going to run and I won’t be able to stop them. If we ride in from the east… hell, sir, I can even have the men dismount along the
…” Hollister was pointing to the eastern edge of the village where a small stream meandered beneath a covered bridge on the main road.
“That will be all, Colonel,” Custer said, dismissing Hollister with a wave.
“Sir, respectfully, I must…”
“You have your orders, Colonel Hollister. Now attend to your duty. Dismissed.”
By instinct, Hollister came to attention and saluted smartly. He turned on his heel and stormed from the tent. He mounted the bay gelding he had ridden for the last several weeks and rode back to his troopers.
“Orders, sir?” His lieutenant, a rawboned redhead by the name of McAndrews asked him.
“Not good, Mac,” Hollister said. “We’re to take up a position south of the orchard, along the fencerow. I don’t like it, Mac. Not one little bit.” Hollister was steamed, but he had very little time to waste.
“Mac, ride to Captain Ferguson. Tell him to take his company east and form a skirmish line along the edge of this orchard. It’s going to get hot for us, and when he hears it start, he’s to ride through those trees like he owes the devil money. Push hard and keep the Rebs occupied. He needs to thin the herd or we are going to get our asses shot to pieces. Do you understand, Mac?”
“Yes, sir,” the young lieutenant said. “I also must respectfully remind the colonel that he was given no such authority to separate his command.”
“Noted,” said Hollister.
“I must also inform the colonel, in case he should think otherwise, General Custer is full of shit. Sir.”
Hollister couldn’t help but laugh. “I’ll forget you said that. Now get moving. Knowing the general, he’ll attack before breakfast. Make sure Ferguson understands.”
He watched McAndrews ride off. He was only two years younger than Hollister but for whatever reason, Jonas felt like a father to him. Being in charge of soldiers in wartime makes a young man old. God, he was being morbid.
“Snap out of it, Jonas,” he muttered to himself. A corporal mounted on a beautiful black stallion heard him talking to himself and smiled. Hollister just shrugged. Custer had him all jangled up. Time to get your mind right, he thought.
He momentarily considered riding for Sheridan’s camp, about three miles north of the town. But he’d never make it back in time and that would leave his men without their commanding officer. Something he would never do. Besides, if he went over Custer’s head, he’d probably regret it. He had a feeling Custer was gaming the orders. Changing them up so he got the maximum glory, while still technically following Sheridan’s command.
He heard a distant bugle sound a call to arms. Shit, he thought.
“All right, Corporal. Sound the order. To your mounts, let’s ride!” Hollister reined his horse around and broke into a slow trot as he heard the order to mount up work its way down the line of his men. The army had bivouacked in a field northeast of the town the night before, but as always, his regiment was mounted up and ready to go in a matter of seconds. His men had waited for their CO to return from his meeting and give the order. Hollister was popular with his troops. He had uncanny field skills and his troopers had come to understand that when he gave an order, it was always the right move-it would take them through the fight with minimum casualties and maximum success. In return, his men were the most able, polished regiment in Sheridan’s whole command.
In less than thirty minutes they reached their objective and Hollister deployed the men along the fencerow. He gave them the order to advance carbines and marveled at how six hundred men drew their rifles from their saddle scabbards almost in unison. What a fine unit. McAndrews returned on his palomino, his face showing some perspiration. He was always a little nervous before the fighting started, but once the first shot sounded, there was not a steadier man.
“Mac, is Ferguson on his way?” Hollister said to the lieutenant. “I think Custer is up to something and I got a feeling a couple thousand rebels are coming through that orchard before long.”
“Yes, sir, he said to tell you he’ll meet you in the middle. I think he liked your idea,” McAndrews said, drawing his carbine from its holster on his saddle. Together, they waited as their horses pawed at the ground and grazed on the grass.
Shortly after sunrise Hollister heard the sounds of the battle start. It was always a puzzle to Jonas how the fighting commenced with the first quiet pops of the long rifles, usually the Enfields the Rebs used. Then the cannon started a few seconds later and it became a cacophony of noise, indistinguishable from either side. Over the sound came the shouts of thousands of men, the Confederates raising their rebel yell while the Union soldiers shouted back. There was never a break in the shouting, as it quickly became a constant roar: the screams as the shooting intensified, the wails of the men as they fell wounded, and the whining cries of dying horses joined in the chorus.
Hollister waited, fidgeting in the saddle. He could not see into the town, as the orchard was densely overgrown. He heard the sound of cavalry approaching from the west. He wondered if it was Custer, and then for a moment worried the Rebs had somehow gathered themselves and sent reinforcements, but it couldn’t be. Sheridan and his 15,000 troops were north.
The first Reb came out of the orchard at a dead run and almost collided with Hollister’s horse. He was startled to find a line of Union soldiers there, but collapsed when a bullet tore through his chest, skidding to a stop a few feet in front of Jonas.
“Hold…” Jonas started to say, but his words trailed off when a bullet whizzed past his left ear. Everything turned to chaos as his men opened fire on an orchard that had come alive with the enemy. He drew his Colt, but saw immediately that his men would be overrun. A wave of gray uniformed soldiers flooded through the trees and the fencerow behind him blocked any hopes to maneuver away.
He had no idea how many times his revolver had clicked on an empty chamber before he realized it was empty.
“Sir, there’s a damn lot of rebels!” Mac shouted to him. And he was right. There were too many. He was going to get his men killed if he didn’t do something quickly.
“Mac, sound the order, about face, retreat! Get the men through that fencerow and get them out of here, go west and regroup on the bridge road. Hurry!” He gave the order to his lieutenant. His pistol was empty and he drew his carbine, as bullets flew everywhere. The wall of fleeing Rebs had pushed his troopers up against the fencerow and before they could move, the ground had become a teeming mass of men and horses, and still more Confederates poured out of the orchard.
“Retreat!” Hollister shouted. “Bugler! Sound retreat.” Nothing happened because his bugler had been killed. Hollister saw three Confederate soldiers riding horses back toward the town, having pulled his troopers from them. It had all turned to shit. God damn Custer.
Hollister spurred his horse, pushing the nervous animal through the mass of men. Retreating to the south was out. “Forward! Move forward!” he shouted. He found some clear space and rode back and forth, exhorting his men. He wanted them to follow him into the orchard to fight their way through the retreating rebels. A few of his men saw him in the confusion and understood his order. But the chaos seemed insurmountable and he saw two more of his men go down.
“Mac! Turn the men! Forward into the orchard! Hurry!” He shouted at Mac and the lieutenant rose in his saddle and shouted, “Forward through the orchard! Return fire! Forw-”
His words died on his lips as a minie ball entered just below his left eye. Mac catapulted off his horse, his body falling to the ground, disappearing among the gray uniforms.
“MAC!” Hollister shouted “NO!” He was about to spur his horse toward the fallen lieutenant, but a hand reached out and grabbed the halter of his mount.
“Sir! No, sir, we’ve got to get into that orchard sir, come on now. The lieutenant is dead, sir, you need to rally the men.” It was a grizzled sergeant named Dawson, from B Company, who had stopped him.
The next hour was lost in Hollister’s mind. He vaguely remembered following Dawson into the orchard. His officers had finally understood what he was asking and had rallied the men through the trees until they reached the south end of the village and the advancing Union line. Custer had routed the Confederates out of the town, just as he predicted, but the general’s actions had driven the Rebs right into Hollister’s regiment, where his men had been chewed up like beef in a meat grinder.
When the buzz of the fight subsided, Hollister returned to the fencerow. It was littered with dead and dying rebels and the medical corpsman had gathered the bodies of his men who had fallen. Thirty-seven bodies were lined in the shade covered by blankets. Hollister sat on his horse staring at the corpses, feeling the anger grow; a small nugget of fire in the center of his chest. No one approached him, asked him for orders, or bothered him. The look on his face was a warning for everyone to stay away. After a while he turned his horse and rode hard for the Union camp.
A half hour later he arrived at General Sheridan’s camp. He could hear the sound of celebration coming from the large campaign tent. He handed the reins to a young private guarding the horses and entered the tent. The noise dimmed as the buzzing in his ears became louder. The edges of his vision turned red, and small arcs of light traveled across his eyes like a summer thunderstorm.
Custer sat at the end of a table, his hat off, revealing his long blond hair tangled with the yellow silk scarf about his neck. He was leaning back in his chair with his legs crossed while vanity oozed from his pores.
He heard the clump of Hollister’s boots behind him, and turned just in time to see the first blow coming. It staggered him and he slumped to the ground, landing awkwardly on his ass. Hollister kicked the chair out of the way and leapt on the prone man.
“You arrogant son of a bitch,” Jonas shouted, and landed another punch on the point of Custer’s chin. His arm was cocked for another swing, but it never landed because someone grabbed him, and he felt himself being lifted to his feet. Custer lay on the ground stunned, blood seeping from his mouth and a cut on his chin.
“Fucking bastard… you no-good prick!” Hollister shouted.
“Colonel Hollister!” Jonas came out of his rage at the sound of General Sheridan’s voice. He didn’t recognize the officers holding him by the arms but the general stood between him and Custer, who still lay on the ground.
“Jesus Christ, Hollister,” the general said. “Are you going to take a swing at me, Colonel?” Jonas’s breath came in ragged gasps but he shook his head.
“Then let him go,” the general said. “Good God, man. What the hell have you done?” Sheridan examined the prone body of Custer on the floor of his tent. He nudged him with the toe of his boot. Sheridan was a short man, no taller than five and a half feet, hence his nickname “Little Phil.” He was as cocky as a rooster and his voice had always sounded how Hollister thought God’s would sound, deep and resonant with just the slightest trace of an Irish brogue. “Sergeant! Get the general to the surgeon. Move it!”
Hollister stood stock still, all the fight gone out of him. He knew he was in trouble, but he didn’t care. All he could see was poor Mac, lying on the ground, his face caved in where the bullet had struck him. A sergeant and two privates entered the tent and lifted Custer from the ground. Hollister didn’t know it then, but that was the last time he would ever see the man.
Finally he was alone with General Sheridan. Little Phil stood with his back to Jonas, massaging his temples.
“Jesus Christ, Jonas! What the hell was this all about?” Hollister stood silent. Sheridan waited for him to speak, finally spinning on his heel and confronting him. “God damn it, Colonel, you’ve got one chance here. You better tell me what happened in the next sixty seconds, or so help me God, I’ll see you shot!”
Hollister instinctively came to attention. He threw his shoulders back and kept his arms straight at his sides.
“Sir! I was ordered by General Custer to the south of the orchard to attack the rebels from the rear… I… ”
“You what?” Sheridan stared hard at him, then the realization of what Custer had done washed over him. He sagged, and started pacing again. “God damn him, those weren’t my orders, I specifically told him not to divide his command! The yellow-haired bastard…” Sheridan began stalking back and forth. The general was a profane man, and also a bigot and a racist. None of those facts affected his ability as a brilliant cavalry commander.
“What happened?” he asked.
“We were overrun. I only had one regiment and there were at least four thousand rebels on the retreat. I lost thirty-seven of my men, General. Including Lieutenant McAndrews, sir…”
“Aw shit, not McAndrews! Kid was going to be something special,” Sheridan interrupted. Hollister went on.
“Sir, I pleaded with General Custer not to split the troops, but he assured me you had given the order.”
“That vainglorious sonuvabitch. Good Christ, Hollister…” General Sheridan’s face was a light shade of purple. “You should have come to me,” he muttered. Knowing full well Hollister had not had the time, nor would Custer have allowed him any such action. He would have viewed Hollister seeking confirmation of Sheridan’s orders as an affront to his command.
“Yes, sir,” Hollister said. It was the only answer he could give. This would be made out to be his fault, he was sure. He saw his mistake in physically attacking Custer. If he’d gone through the right channels, gotten Custer’s order on the record, he might have gotten somewhere. Now he was headed for a court-martial at least, a firing squad at worst. And if Sheridan didn’t have him thrown in the stockade, he would have to watch his back now for as long as Custer remained in the army. He wouldn’t let Hollister get away with this, no matter what the official outcome.
Sheridan didn’t say anything else for several minutes. Hollister thought the next words out of his mouth would be an order to surrender himself to custody.
“All right. I’ll deal with Custer. The thing is, Colonel Hollister, I can’t court-martial him or you. I believe you, Jonas. But this story can’t get out, or all of us will be fucked once Sam gets word.” Sam was General Grant, commander of the Army of the Potomac. “Sam can’t stand Custer and he only barely tolerates me because I win, the drunken bastard.”
“I know the skinny, shit-eating little prick wanted to be the one to chase the rebels out of the town and cut them up in the orchard so he could be the hero. And he put your men in the shitter along the way. He’s a pompous son of a bitch and we both know it. But he’s winning his fights. He’s all over the papers, and as much as Sam hates his guts, he likes the good publicity. Grant has the personality of a horse turd and can’t stand talking to the press. So he’s happy to have someone like that cocksucker Custer woo the reporters. If he’s court-martialed the press will crucify us.” Sheridan ran his hands through his salt-and-pepper hair in frustration. “Jesus Christ, man.”
“So that’s it, sir, he gets my men killed and that’s it? He gets away with it?” Hollister felt the anger welling inside him again.
“Grow the hell up, Colonel. That’s not it, and you goddamned well know it. Are you right? Yes of course, god damn it. But you’re going to take it. Go back to your regiment. See to your men and you leave Custer to me. I’m going to bust you but there won’t be a court-martial. Consider yourself one lucky bastard. Now get your sorry ass out of my sight. Report here at oh five hundred for staff meeting and orders.”
Hollister stood still, seething. He was about to open his mouth.
“Don’t you say a goddamn word to me, Colonel! Get out of my sight or swear to fucking God I’ll shoot you myself!” Sheridan put his hand on his sidearm for emphasis and dismissed Hollister with a wave, returning to his desk.
As mad as he was, he also realized he was lucky. He knew Sheridan thought highly of him, but he had no indication that the General held him in such regard. He was about to voice his thanks, when Little Phil interrupted him, turning back from his seat.
“So help me God, if you open your mouth you’ll be digging latrines until this war is over. Do you understand me? I want you gone, and I mean now.”
“Yes, sir,” said Hollister saluting smartly as he left the tent. He worked things over in his mind. The word of the dust-up spread through the camp like the clap. Men whispered and pointed at him as he walked back to his horse. He met no one’s gaze. Some of the men here were firmly in Custer’s corner and wouldn’t hesitate to give him a thrashing if he provoked them. Others knew Custer was dangerous. And as far as they were concerned, his beating had come far too late.
The next day Custer was absent from the staff meeting. Word had worked its way back to Hollister that the yellow-haired general had been unconscious for hours with a broken jaw. When the officers convened at Sheridan’s tent the next morning, no one mentioned the missing general, and Sheridan was his usual brusque self. Hollister had spent the evening writing letters to the families of the men who had died the day before, but as had happened before and would happen again before the war was over, he found there was little time to grieve. Orders were delivered, the battle plan discussed, and they were dismissed. The fight was forgotten for the time being. There was another battle ahead of them and it required complete focus.
The following week, Hollister was transferred to the 4 th U.S. Cavalry. The 4 th was regular army and kept him out of Custer’s orbit, and a little less than a year later, the war was over.
Custer secured his notoriety for chasing Lee to Appomattox Courthouse from the west. He never spoke to Hollister again. Jonas had narrowly avoided a career-killing mistake.
The army shrank rapidly with the war’s end. Hollister reenlisted and stayed in the 4 th. He had no intention of going home. Like most officers who stayed in the regular army after the war, he was reduced in rank to lieutenant and posted first at Fort Laramie. Sheridan was put in charge of the Indian wars and he made sure to keep Hollister away from Custer when it came to assignments. And then came that morning on the plains in Wyoming, where everything went wrong. There were times, as he wrote to everyone he knew during the first year inside Leavenworth, when he was certain his thrashing of Custer had kept some in the army from coming to his defense.
A sharp blast of the train whistle brought Hollister back to the present. He wondered if he would get used to the rickety motion of the car and be able to sleep. The events of the day still tumbled around in his mind like autumn leaves caught in a whirlwind. He had gone from digging holes in Leavenworth to being on his way west on a special assignment in a matter of hours. Then there were Pinkerton and his friend Van Helsing. What odd men they were. And he had dragged Chee along not knowing he came complete with a goddamn giant dog. It was a lot to grasp and he could only think of one thing to say before sleep over took him.
“Huh.”