“It’s not my case, right?”
“Is that a rhetorical question?”
“I guess so.”
“Well, I’ve never been much for rhetoric, so why don’t you just tell me what’s on your mind, and why I ought to doubt your sanity.”
The lieutenant said it lightly, with just the right blend of humor and understanding, and Shepherd knew he had underestimated the man.
He shouldn’t have. He should have remembered how Paul Brookings had been there for him during the hellish days when Ginnie was hospitalized, and the still worse months after her death.
At the hospital Brookings had visited Shepherd and Ginnie every day. Twice he had stayed up nearly all night with Shepherd, the two of them sitting together in an alcove near a noisy freight elevator. Shepherd talking aimlessly, the lieutenant doing the work of listening.
The morning Ginnie died. Shepherd had called Brookings, waking him in the dawn twilight. Brookings had handled most of the details — paperwork, funeral arrangements — while Shepherd drifted in a mist of grief.
Later, there had been fishing trips, long walks, dinners at Brookings’ house where Paul’s wife, Chloris, served homemade, multicourse meals and soft music played.
Brookings had nursed Shepherd through the hardest part of his life. Of course he was the right person, the only person, for Shepherd to turn to now.
“Okay,” Shepherd said. “Here it is. I talked to Chuck Wheelihan over in Graham County a few hours ago. He told me some things that got me thinking. I don’t know why, really. It’s nothing specific. But I can’t seem to let it go.”
“Not sure I follow you. The woman’s under arrest. As I understand it, no one’s ever disputed the fact that she killed her husband.”
“No.”
“And she accused her psychiatrist of being the White Mountains Killer. So she’s clearly delusional. Right?”
Shepherd hesitated, and Brookings pursed his lips.
“Oh,” the lieutenant said. “You think maybe she’s not delusional.”
“I don’t know if I’d go that far.” Shepherd felt himself backing away from his suspicions, which seemed so obscure, so insubstantial, now that they were on the verge of being stated aloud. “I don’t know what to think,” he added lamely.
Brookings was quiet for a moment. He played with a stapler on his desk. On the street below, a car’s horn squalled briefly.
“This isn’t like you, Roy,” Brookings said finally. “When a case is cleared, you let it go. What’s different now?”
“It just feels incomplete. But hell, you’re right. I’m probably just getting carried away.”
“I didn’t say that.”
“Forget it, okay? Forget I was even here.”
He took a step toward the door. Brookings stopped him with a command. “Hold on.”
Shepherd turned to look at him. The lieutenant clicked the stapler again, then raised his head to meet Shepherd’s gaze.
“It’s Ginnie,” Brookings said softly, “isn’t it?”
“What’s she got to do with this?”
“A lot, I think. Maybe everything. You can’t bring her back, Roy.”
Shepherd stiffened. “I’m fairly certain I already knew that.”
“Too late to save her. You wish you could. So you try to save the next one. You try to get all the crazies off the street.”
“I don’t really see where this is going.”
“Sure you do. It’s why you went after the McMillan woman so hard. Above and beyond the call of duty. You needed to put her away, because she was another Tim Fries. Another lighted fuse.”
“All right. So what?”
“Now you’re having second thoughts. But you don’t want to admit it. You don’t want to help her in any way. Helping her feels like a betrayal. Like you’re letting Ginnie die all over again.”
Shepherd didn’t answer.
“It’s not a betrayal, Roy.”
“I don’t know. Maybe it is.”
“No. Take a look at this woman, Kaylie McMillan. Who is she, really? She’s been on the run for years. Got no money, no home. Scared all the time. Looking for help. Maybe she’s a psycho. Probably she is. Or maybe not. Either way, there’s one thing about her we can say for sure.”
“What?”
“She’s exactly the kind of person your wife would have wanted to help.”
Shepherd nodded slowly. He thought of Ginnie in her study, working on her Internet project to aid the homeless. He thought of her in the health clinic, welcoming the people of the street.
“That’s true,” he said, his voice low.
“It’s only a betrayal if you don’t help her. So go. Do whatever you have to do.”
“I need to talk to Kaylie’s father-in-law. He seems to think she shouldn’t be locked up.”
“Sounds like a conversation worth having. Just don’t break any speed limits to get there.”
“I won’t.” Shepherd felt lighter suddenly. “Thanks, Paul. Thanks.”
“Just doing my job.”
“I don’t know if this kind of thing is part of the job description. Maybe you should’ve been a shrink.”
“And give up a civil service salary? I don’t think so. Now get going. Traffic’s already getting bad out there.”
Shepherd was at the door when Brookings added in a quieter voice, “And, Roy?”