Back on the island, Walter read Isobel’s story about the infamous Leonard Martin while enjoying breakfast in his usual spot in Billy’s Bar. On St. John, the New York Times comes ashore with the early morning ferry from the rock. The distribution began with Billy’s because it was right on the square, only steps from where the ferry docked, plus it was well known that Walter Sherman liked to read it with breakfast. They do know everything. The story detailed the things Walter and Isobel talked about, and, while it was news on the most striking order for the world at large, it provided no new information for him. He read every word, examined every graphic: the rifles and ammo, the player chart that was spread out on the page as if they were each key members of the underworld. He couldn’t help feeling there was something missing. He didn’t know what, but he knew enough to keep that uneasy sense in a special file for future reference.
That Sunday he watched the interview with Ed Bradley on the television Tom Maloney had thought of as Radio City. Clara saw it too. She knew something about Walter’s job, although she had never heard him refer to what he did as a job. He did something for people they couldn’t do for themselves, something important, something she was sure was dangerous-that she knew. All those trips he took. Now, looking at Isobel Gitlin talking to one of her favorite TV personalities, that handsome Ed Bradley, telling him she had discovered this man, Leonard Martin, all by herself-Clara wondered just what it was that Mr. Sherman really did.
St. John
“Still got nothing to say?” Billy asked. Walter had been sitting in his regular seat at the bar in silence nursing the same Diet Coke all morning. He hardly ate his breakfast, and the New York Times lay folded on the bar, unopened. Walter muttered something at Billy, nothing he could make sense of.
“I knew a man once,” Ike said. “Didn’t say nothing to nobody for damn near two months.”
“Who was that?” Billy asked, astonished.
“Isaac. You know him, Billy? Runs that Budweiser stand over near the beach.”
“The hot dog place?” Billy said, clarifying things. “It’s got that big Budweiser sign on it? Yeah, I know him.”
“Well, like I said. Nothing to nobody for two months.”
“You said ‘damn near two months,’ not ‘two months’.”
“Thank God A’mighty!” hollered Ike, managing not to cough in spite of the prodigious puff of smoke coming out of his mouth simultaneous with his words. “Walter, you can talk.”
“Better than the two of you.”
“I talk pretty good,” Billy said, a tiny bit of hurt in his voice. “You know, you can’t run a bar, not one as popular as this, and not be a good talker.” Walter nodded, but clearly not in agreement. Ike took another deep drag, the sound of the burning embers racing toward the butt, carrying all the way to where Walter sat.
“Christ, Ike,” he said. “You’re going to explode. So, are you going to tell us?”
“Tell us what?” Billy said.
“Alright Ike,” said Walter, putting on his best third-grade teacher voice, “why didn’t Isaac say anything for… however long you said?”
“Well,” Ike said, “I can only tell you what he told me-later on, of course. He said he didn’t have nothing to say.” Walter stared at Ike, the question of the old man’s credibility written all over his face. Ike, as always, smiled.
“Best talker I ever heard was Hitler,” Billy said, and neither Walter nor Ike could think of what to say next. They looked at each other with flat amazement. Finally, Walter said, “Hitler?” And Ike followed with, “Shit,” sounding more like bed linen than anything else. Billy rose to his own defense.
“Hey, I don’t like him. I’m just saying, did you ever hear him speak, talking? I’ve seen him on The History Channel. I don’t even know what he’s saying, but I couldn’t take my eyes off him. And then that crowd-all those Germans-yelling like that. All I’m saying is I never heard anyone else talk that way. That’s all.”
“I have,” Walter said. “Ever hear of Martin Luther King, Jr.?”
Billy picked up a rag and began wiping down the already spotless bar. His embarrassment was painful. Walter knew Billy wouldn’t be the next to say anything. Then Ike spoke up.
“Minister Henry Broomfield,” he said. “Come here a long time ago, must be forty years. Preached three weekends in a row, mind you. Out by the old slave battleground. In a tent. Went back and stayed on the rock during the week. Everybody went that first weekend. Ain’t that many of us here, right? And not much to do neither. But we went back again the next week, and then again another time just to hear that man talk. Spellbinder. For a few days after he’d gone I was this close to seeing Jesus myself.” Ike held up one finger on each hand about a foot between them. He laughed, and Walter did too.
“Powerful, huh?” Billy said, feeling a bit rehabilitated. Jesus and Hitler were equally irrelevant to him.
“And that wasn’t the best part,” said Ike. “You see, Minister Broomfield come here only once and leave. But he come back a few years ago-thirty, thirty-five years later. He sets up his tent in the same exact spot as before. We all went. Why not? My wife-” Ike stopped and took a very deep breath, this time without the cigarette. Walter remembered when Sissy died about a year before Billy arrived on St. John. The old man needed a minute. “We all went,” Ike continued, “and my wife wanted to speak to Minister Broomfield after his services, so she waits in line to see him and I’m waiting with her. Well, Sissy finally gets to shake his hand and she says something like, ‘I bet you don’t remember me, but I heard you when you were here before-twice, actually.’ That minister looked right into her eyes with a big smile, held her hands with both of his-you know, sort of like he was Christ himself-and he says to her, ‘Of course I remember you, darlin’. And your sister too.’”
“That’s impressive,” Walter said.
“Let me tell you,” Ike went on. “I was shocked. How this man remember Sissy’s sister? Sissy’s so happy she just sort of drifts away and I’m left standing there, just me and Minister Henry Broomfield. I look at him and say how could he remember my wife’s sister after maybe forty years? Her sister! That man put his hand on my shoulder, and with that same smile he just gave my Sissy he whispers to me, ‘They all got sisters.’”
The three friends were silent. What more was there to say. At last Billy said, “Sonofabitch. You want me to write it?”
“That’s good,” Ike said.
“How can people vote for this one?” asked Walter.
“How can they vote for any of them?” said Billy. “Nobody’s got the slightest fucking idea what this stuff is all about.”
“Okay,” Walter said, looking over to Ike for approval.
“That’s good,” the old man said again.
“Well then,” Billy said. He rambled over to the chalkboard next to the ancient cash register and, for the time being, a miniature Christmas tree, picked up the blue chalk, and wrote, “Hitler/Martin Luther King, Jr./Henry Broomfield.”
Walter ordered a fresh Diet Coke and Billy’s special swordfish steak with everything-the salad and potatoes too. He was hungry at last. And he was thinking, “They all got sisters.”